LA PLATA — Councilman Gregory Sampson Jr. says he was the only member of the Town Council to vote on Nov. 10 to keep Mayor Jeannine James as presiding officer, and that he did so because he does not think a council should change who runs its meetings in the middle of a term.
Sampson laid out his reasoning in a Ward III newsletter emailed to residents over the weekend. He wrote that he supported giving the council authority to pick its own presiding officer, but that voters elected the current council, mayor included, “under a specific set of rules and expectations.” The better course, he wrote, would have been to adopt the new procedure now and use it at the start of the next term.
The newsletter does not say how the other members voted, how the mayor voted on her own place in the chair, or who won. The town has not yet posted minutes of the Nov. 10 meeting, and the Chronicle has not independently confirmed the result of the roll call. The town’s public record so far is the meeting agenda and a 647-page packet on its meeting portal.
How the Nov. 10 election was set up
Item 5.3 on the Nov. 10 agenda asked the council to adopt a special rule of procedure and elect its first Council Chair. A staff summary in the packet says the chair needs a majority of all five members, which means three votes whether or not every member is present. The mayor and all four council members were eligible to be elected and to vote.
Staff recommended a roll call in the council’s customary order, Ward I, Ward II, Ward III, Ward IV and then the mayor, with each member naming a nominee. The summary says the minutes would record each round and how each member voted. If no one reached three votes, the roll call would repeat, with the lowest vote-getter dropping out after the third round, and staff proposed a continuance to Nov. 24 only as a last resort. Staff also recommended naming a vice chair to preside when the chair is absent.
The chair elected Nov. 10 takes office at the council’s next meeting and serves until the May 2027 organizational meeting, according to the packet. The town’s portal now lists the Nov. 24 council meeting as canceled, so it is not yet clear when the new chair’s first meeting will be.
Two votes, two dates
Sampson’s newsletter describes “two separate votes” on Nov. 10: one amending the charter, and one choosing the presiding officer. The town’s packet dates the charter change differently. The council adopted Charter Amendment Resolution 26-50 on Sept. 8, and the town received no qualified referendum petition by the Oct. 18 deadline, so it took effect Oct. 28, according to the staff summary. The Nov. 10 vote was the election the legislation required.
Sampson was part of the 4-1 majority in September, as the Chronicle reported when the council voted to curb the mayor’s authority. James cast the lone no vote. In her closing remarks that night, she said changing an elected office’s powers “during an incumbent’s term” was the wrong way to settle disagreements among five current officeholders. Sampson’s reasoning now tracks that point.
He had signaled the hesitation before. In an email to the Chronicle the day after the Oct. 13 meeting, he said he was “still considering whether changing the Presiding Officer in the middle of a term is the right decision.” He also said he holds “no personal animosity toward the Mayor,” that “each council member still has one vote,” and that he hopes a future council explores a stand-alone mayor’s office. The Chronicle reported that in its story on the petition deadline, where residents also urged the council to drop the change or put it to voters.
A council in conflict
The change followed months of friction. The council voted 4-1 on Aug. 18 to censure James over a state highway-safety appointment, and town staff have said discussion of the charter changes began at a June 9 meeting, before the censure. The state Open Meetings Compliance Board has found the council violated the Open Meetings Act three times since June 2025, most recently in an Oct. 15 opinion on the closed session before the censure. Each time the problem was how the council disclosed or documented its business, and the board’s opinions are advisory. The same board cleared the council in a protest-sign dispute in an opinion dated Nov. 6.
Sampson’s newsletter also covered small-business proposals that staff agreed to bring back, which the Chronicle covered in a separate story, and the state’s review of a traffic signal at Catalpa Drive and U.S. 301.
What comes next
Staff recommended that the council direct it to return with a Rules of Procedure amendment formally creating a vice chair, along with a conforming change to the town code, before the May 2027 organizational meeting. Under the new rules the council can choose a different presiding officer at that meeting, a point Sampson noted in his newsletter. The Chronicle will update this story when the town posts the minutes of the Nov. 10 meeting.
