LA PLATA — St. Charles homeowners who want to add a deck, shed or fence will no longer need a village design board’s sign-off once their house is built, after Charles County commissioners approved an agreement Tuesday that county planners say could shrink permit waits from as long as six months to two or three weeks.

The Board of County Commissioners approved the memorandum of understanding by voice vote on Nov. 17, with Commissioner Ralph Patterson II absent. The agreement is between the county and St. Charles Community LLC, and it puts in writing changes the county Planning Commission approved Oct. 19, which the Chronicle previewed Oct. 26. It does not amend Docket 90, the 1972 planning document that governs the St. Charles planned unit development, planners said, which leaves room to adjust the arrangement later.

What changes for homeowners

Each of St. Charles’s villages has its own Plan Design Review Board, or PDRB, a body that reviews architecture and land use on behalf of the Planning Commission. Until now, a resident building a deck typically went to a neighborhood homeowners association, then the village PDRB, then the county for a building permit.

Under the agreement, PDRBs will still approve architectural drawings for the initial construction of a home. Once a home has its use and occupancy permit, later projects such as fences, decks and sheds go straight to the county, and residents can seek homeowners association approval at the same time. County planning staff said the permit application will carry a statement that the applicant remains responsible for following neighborhood covenants and restrictions.

Staff said the process now takes three to six months and could drop to two or three weeks, depending on how often a homeowners association meets. Larger projects are not covered: an accessory dwelling unit, which adds a new structure, would still go to the design board for the resident’s village, staff told a commissioner who asked.

What changes for small businesses

On the commercial side, the county alone will approve a change of ownership or a new tenant when the use stays the same. A restaurant that changes hands, or one restaurant replacing another, no longer needs PDRB review. The county can also approve temporary signs on its own, so a new business can advertise while its permanent sign goes through review.

PDRBs keep review of new development, changes of use, exterior modifications and permanent signs. A warehouse converting to a church would still go to the board, staff said. Planners said businesses had been losing weeks of revenue and paying rent on empty space while waiting for a design board to approve a use that was not changing.

Why the county acted

Planning and Growth Management Director Jason Groth and staff described a system that frustrated residents and landowners: layered approvals, unclear guidelines, limited public information and boards that were slow to respond. The county often ended up as the go-between, they said. A work group of county staff, St. Charles Community, the PDRB administrators and the developer Lennar has met for about two and a half years.

Two management firms run the boards. A law firm manages the PDRBs for St. Charles Town Center, Fairway Village Commercial, Wooded Glen and Piney Reach, and Clemens Bay Management Group manages those for Smallwood, Westlake and Fairway Village residential. Staff said the Civic Alliance of homeowners association presidents and some individual presidents supported the change.

The memorandum also sets expectations for the boards themselves, including how they communicate with applicants, how often they meet and how they keep records. A website to explain who approves what is in the works.

Commissioners’ reactions

Commissioner Thomasina Coates, whose district does not include St. Charles, said she wished planners had briefed Patterson individually first, since the community is in his district. Planners said he knew the work was under way and had raised resident complaints with them over the past two years, but that he had not received a separate briefing on this presentation. Coates said she saw most of the changes as improvements and hoped the document would stay open to more.

Another commissioner said she had looked for the boards’ meeting schedule, membership and minutes on their website and could not find them, and asked planners to make sure the new site answers who, what, when and where. Planners said it would.

Staff said next steps include consistent procedures across the boards, outreach to homeowners associations, residents, business owners and the real estate community, and further work on transparency. Earlier Tuesday, commissioners heard Lennar’s annual Docket 90 update, which put roughly 4,500 homes left to build in St. Charles.

David M. Higgins II is an award-winning journalist and founder of The Southern Maryland Chronicle. A Baltimore native raised in Southern Maryland, Higgins founded the Chronicle in 2017 and has built it...

Leave a comment