BALTIMORE — The state Open Meetings Compliance Board has found that the Calvert County Board of County Commissioners did not violate the Open Meetings Act in a July 28 closed session, rejecting every allegation in a resident’s complaint.

The board’s opinion, 20 OMCB Opinions 336, is dated Nov. 12. The three-member board reviewed the sealed minutes of the closed session before ruling.

What the complaint alleged

The commissioners went into closed session on July 28 under the personnel exception in the Open Meetings Act. That exception allows a public body to meet privately to discuss the appointment, discipline, compensation, removal or evaluation of an appointee, employee or official over whom it has jurisdiction, or any other personnel matter affecting specific individuals.

The complainant said that immediately afterward he was issued a trespass notice and effectively banned from a private model boat club that uses county property. From that, he inferred the commissioners had discussed him behind closed doors. He argued the personnel exception did not allow that, because he is not an employee, appointee or official under the board’s jurisdiction. The opinion does not name him or say in which county the club’s property sits.

He raised two more claims: that the commissioners improperly discussed “future appointments affecting a class of citizen volunteers,” and that the public minutes failed to reflect either topic.

How the board ruled

On the first claim, the board said the commissioners told it they did not discuss the complainant, and that nothing in the closed-session minutes suggested they did.

On the second, the board noted that the personnel exception covers specifically identifiable individuals, not general personnel matters applying to a whole class of people. After reviewing the minutes, it concluded the commissioners kept their discussion to specific individuals.

The third claim fell with the first two. State law requires a public body to summarize a closed session in its next open-session minutes, but because the commissioners did not discuss the topics the complainant listed, the board found no violation there either. By law, the board keeps closed-session minutes confidential and describes them only in general terms.

Part of a busy month for the board

The Calvert opinion follows another Southern Maryland ruling. Earlier this month, the Chronicle reported that the board cleared the La Plata council in a protest sign dispute.

David M. Higgins II is an award-winning journalist and founder of The Southern Maryland Chronicle. A Baltimore native raised in Southern Maryland, Higgins founded the Chronicle in 2017 and has built it...

Leave a comment